In the wake of a BBC Panorama documentary fueling claims of ADHD "over-diagnosis," journalist Diyora Shadijanova (Women's Health Magazine), living with the condition, provides a perspective that shifts the focus from alleged over-diagnosis to a more critical issue: NHS underfunding.
Unraveling the Over-Diagnosis Debate
Recent headlines suggesting an "ADHD epidemic" and scepticism surrounding diagnoses have stirred a moral panic. Diyora challenges the growing fear that ADHD is being over-diagnosed and sheds light on the deeper problem overshadowed by this discourse.
BBC Panorama: Narrow Focus and Missed Opportunities
The recent Panorama documentary, "Private ADHD Clinics Exposed," investigates potential malpractices in private clinics. While highlighting valid concerns, Diyora argues that the narrow focus missed the opportunity to address the underlying issue—the increasing demand for ADHD services due to heightened awareness and an underfunded NHS.
The Changing Landscape of ADHD Diagnoses
Diyora emphasizes a shift in the ADHD narrative, attributing the rise in diagnoses to reduced stigma and increased awareness, especially among traditionally under-diagnosed groups. Data supports this, with estimates suggesting 2.6 million people in the UK have ADHD, a substantial increase from 120,000 diagnoses a few years ago.
Expert Insights: Over-Diagnosis or Catching Up?
Experts, including Dr. Mike Smith, featured in the Panorama documentary, argue that the surge in assessments is not indicative of over-diagnosis but rather a natural catch-up to the actual prevalence of ADHD. Diyora advocates for a broader understanding of this context.
Private Clinics: A Critical Issue Amid NHS Challenges
While acknowledging potential issues in some private clinics, Diyora underscores the pressing concern—underqualified staff and profit-driven practices. The Royal College of Psychiatrists emphasizes the need for comprehensive assessments for proper care, highlighting the potential consequences of subpar private clinic practices.
NHS Underfunding: The Heart of the Matter
Diyora urges a shift in focus from alleged over-diagnosis to the fundamental problem of NHS underfunding. Thirteen years of Tory governance, she argues, have resulted in lengthy waiting lists, pushing individuals toward private clinics promising quicker results.
Personal Perspective: Navigating Underfunded NHS Mental Health Services
Sharing her personal experience, Diyora reveals the challenges she faced with NHS underfunding when seeking mental health help. Her decision to opt for a private ADHD assessment, a privilege not accessible to many, stemmed from the urgency of her situation and the prolonged NHS waiting times.
A Call for Change: Fixing the System
Diyora concludes by emphasizing the need for government intervention to address the root issue—underfunding in NHS mental health services. Until this crucial gap is addressed, individuals seeking ADHD assessments will remain caught between the inadequacies of the system.
Read Diyora Shadijanova's full article for a nuanced perspective on the ADHD discourse and the imperative need for NHS investment.
Comments